Access to remedy for victims of corporate human rights abuse
Civil liability litigation in Europe, enforcement in Latin America
Mots-clés :
Business and human rights, Access to remedy, Civil Liability, Private international law, Cross-border recognition and enforcement of judgmentsRésumé
In the challenging search for access to effective remedies for victims of corporate human rights abuse and environmental harm, there has been a growing trend of transnational civil liability litigation before European courts. This trend raises private international law questions regarding the cross-border recognition and enforcement of judgments, which is an essential part of access to justice. Focusing on litigation before European courts ensuing from corporate human rights abuse in Latin America, this article demonstrates the role of rules on recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments in Latin America by providing concrete examples of ongoing cases. Moreover, the suitability of the new 2019 Judgments Convention and of domestic rules on recognition and enforcement for such transnational business and human rights litigation is analyzed. The article demonstrates that the role of cross-border recognition and enforcement rules should not be over- nor underestimated, and that despite a number of shortcomings, the 2019 Judgments Convention can be an important step forward in this regard.
Téléchargements
Références
ALBORNOZ, María Mercedes. Mexico. In: BASEDOW, Jürgen, RÜHL, Giesela, FERRARI, Franco and DE MIGUEL ASENSIO, Pedro (eds.). Encyclopedia of Private International Law. Edward Elgar Publishing, 2333-2345, 2017.
ARCHER, Simon. The Trafigura Actions as Problems of Transnational Law. In: MUIR WATT, Horatia (ed.), Global Private International Law: Adjudication without Frontiers. Edward Elgar Publishing, 2019.
ARISTOVA, Ekaterina. Private International Law and Corporate Accountability for Human Rights Violations. In: KONRAD, Duden (ed.), IPR für eine Bessere Welt. Mohr Siebeck, 2022.
BRIGHT, Claire and WRAY, Benedict S. Corporations and Social Environmental Justice: The Role of Private International Law. European University Institute Law Working Paper 2012/02.
CABRERA COLORADO, Orlando Federico. Mexico. In: GARB, Louis and Lew, Julian D.M. (eds.). Enforcement of Foreign Judgments: Volume 1. Kluwer, April 2021.
CAMARGO RODRIGUES, Adriana. Brazil. In: GARB, Louis and Lew, Julian D.M. (eds.). Enforcement of Foreign Judgments: Volume 1. Kluwer, March 2022.
CANTÚ RIVERA, Humberto (ed.). Experiencias Latinoamericanas sobre reparación en materia de empresas y derechos humanos. Konrad Adenauer Stiftung and Global Business and Human Rights Scholars Association: América Latina.
CHAMBERS, Rachel and BERGER-WALLISER, Gerlinde. The Future of International Corporate Human Rights Litigation: A Transatlantic Comparison, American Business Law Journal 58/3, 2021.
CONTRERAS VACA, Francisco José. Comentarios al Convenio de La Haya del 2 de julio de 2019 sobre Reconocimiento y Ejecución de Sentencias Extranjeras en materia civil y comercial. Revista Mexicana Derecho Internacional Privado y Comparado 45, 2021.
COSSART, Sandra and CHATELAIN, Lucie. Human Rights Litigation against Multinational Companies in France. In: MEERAN, Richard and MEERAN, Jahan (eds.). Human rights litigation against multinationals in practice. Oxford University Press, 2021.
DE ARAUJO, Nadia. Direito Internacional Privado: Teoria E Prática Brasileira, 8th ed. Thomson Reuters, 2019.
DE ARAUJO, Nadia and DE NARDI, Marcelo. Projeto de Sentenças Estrangeiras da Conferência de Haia: por um regime global de circulaçao internacional de sentenças em matéria civil e comercial. Revista Estudos Institucionais 2, 707-735, 2016.
DE ARAUJO, Nadia, DE NARDI, Marcelo, LOPES, Inez and Polido, Fabrício. The Hague Conference’s Judgments Project: highlights of the text and advantages for Latin America. Revista de Direito Internacional: Crônicas de Direito Internacional Privado 16/1, 18-34, 2019.
DOLINGER, Jacob and TIBURCIO, Carmen. Private International Law in Brazil. Kluwer Law International, 2017.
ECHEGARAY DE MAUSSION, Carlos. El Derecho Internacional Privado en el contexto internacional actual: Las reglas de competencia judicial indirecta en el Convenio de la Haya de 2 de julio de 2019 y el acceso a la justicia. Revista mexicana de Derecho internacional privado y comparado 45, 128-139, 2021.
ENNEKING, Liesbeth. Judicial Remedies: The Issue of Applicable Law. In: ÁLVAREZ RUBIO, Juan José and YIANNIBAS, Katerina (eds.). Human Rights in Business. Routledge, 2017.
European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA), ‘Business and Human Rights: Access to Remedy’, 2020, available at https://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra_uploads/fra-2020-business-human-rights_en.pdf.
European Parliament Committee on Legal Affairs, Draft Report with Recommendations to the Commission on Corporate Due Diligence and Corporate Accountability, 2020/2129(INL).
FERNÁNDEZ ARROYO, Diego P. Adjudicating public interests by private means: the inescapable involvement of States in the Chevron/Ecuador saga. In: MUIR WATT, Horatia, BÍZIKOVÁ, Lucia, BRANDÃO DE OLIVEIRA, Agatha and FERNÁNDEZ ARROYO, Diego P. (eds.). Global Private International Law. Edward Elgar Publishing, 2019.
GARCIMARTÍN, Francisco. El convenio de La Haya de 2 de julio de 2019 sobre reconocimiento y ejecución de sentencias: una primera aproximación. Revista Electrónica de Estudios Internacionales, Crónicade Derecho Internacional Privado 38, December 2019, available at: https://repositorio.comillas.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/11531/44114/REEII%20DICIEMBRE%202019.pdf?sequence=%20-1.
GODDARD, David and BEAUMONT, Paul, Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil or Commercial Matters. In: BEAUMONT, Paul and HOLLIDAY, Jayne (eds.), A Guide to Global Private International Law. Hart Publishing, 2022.
GÓMEZ, Manuel A. A Sour Battle in Lago Agrio and Beyond: The Metamorphosis of Transnational Litigation and the Protection of Collective Rights in Ecuador, FIU Legal Studies Research Paper Series, Research Paper No. 15-35, December 2015.
GONZÁLEZ MARTÍN, Nuria and RODRÍGUEZ JIMÉNEZ, Sonia. Derecho internacional privado: Parte general. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 2010, available at http://ru.juridicas.unam.mx/xmlui/handle/123456789/12165.
HCCH, GARCIMARTÍN Francisco and SAUMIER Geneviève. Explanatory Report on the Convention of 2 July 2019 on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments in Civil or Commercial Matters, available at https://assets.hcch.net/docs/a1b0b0fc-95b1-4544-935b-b842534a120f.pdf.
JAMES-ELUYODE, Jide. Corporate Responsibility and Human Rights: Global Trends and Issues Concerning Indigenous Peoples. Lexington Books, 2019.
KHOURY, Stefanie and WHYTE, David, Corporate Human Rights Violations: Global Prospects for Legal Action. Routledge, 2017.
LINDT, Angela. Transnational Human Rights Litigation: A Means of Obtaining Effective Remedy Abroad? Journal of Legal Anthropology 4(2), 2020, p. 71.
MARÍN FUENTES, José Luis. Reflexiones sobre la figura del exequátur desarrollada por el Tratado de Derecho Procesal Internacional de Montevideo de 1889 y su influencia en el contexto procesal Latinoamericano. In: FRESNEDO DE AGUIRRE, Cecilia and LORENZO IDIARTE, Gonzalo A. Legado y futuro de sus soluciones en el concierto internacional actual: 130 Aniversario de los Tratados de Montevideo de 1889. Montevideo: Fundación de Cultura Universitaria, 2019.
MARX, Axel et al. Access to Legal Remedies for Victims of Corporate Human Rights Abuses in Third Countries. Study for the European Parliament, 2019.
MICHAELS, Ralf; RUIZ ABOU-NIGM, Verónica; VAN LOON, Hans (eds.). The Private Side of Transforming our World - UN Sustainable Development Goals 2030 and the Role of Private International Law. Cambridge: Intersentia, 2021, https://www.intersentiaonline.com/library/the-private-side-of-transforming-our-world-un-sustainable-development-goals-2030-and-the-role-of-p.
NGUYEN, Thu Thuy. Transnational corporations and environmental pollution in Vietnam: Realising the potential of private international law in environmental protection. Journal of Private International Law 18:2, 238-265, 2022.
PEREZNIETO CASTRO, Leonel. Derecho internacional privado: parte general (10a edición). Oxford University Press México, 2015.
PEREZNIETO CASTRO, Leonel. Notas sobre el derecho internacional privado en América Latina. Boletín Mexicano de Derecho Comparado 144, September-December, 1063-1081, 2015.
ROUAS, Virginie. Achieving Access to Justice in a Business and Human Rights Context: An Assessment of Litigation and Regulatory Responses in European Civil-Law Countries. London: University of London Press, 2022.
SECK, Sara L. and OGUNRANTI, Akinwumi. Accountability: Legal Risks and Remedies. In: Corporate Social Responsibility – Sustainable Business: Environmental, Social and Governance Frameworks for the 21st Century. Kluwer Law International, 685-610, 2020.
SILVA SILVA, Jorge Alberto. Reconocimiento y ejecución de sentencias de Estados Unidos de América en México. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 2011, available at https://biblio.juridicas.unam.mx/bjv/id/3006.
SPITZ, Lidia. Homologação De Decisões Estrangeiras No Brasil: A Convenção de Sentenças da Conferência da Haia de 2019 e o contrôle indireto da jurisdição estrangeira. Arraes Editores, 2021, p. 394.
TAKAHASHI, Koji and TANG, Zheng Sophia. Collective Redress. In: BEAUMONT, Paul and HOLLIDAY, Jayne (eds.), A Guide to Global Private International Law. Hart Publishing, 2022.
VAN DAM, Cees and TIEMERSMA, Heleen. Mainstreaming Human Rights in Sustainable Business. In: Mainstreaming Sustainable Business: 20 years Business-Society Management, 20 years impact? Rotterdam: Stichting Maatschappij en Onderneming, 262-268, 2018.
VAN LOON, Hans. At the Cross-roads of Public and Private International Law: The Hague Conference on Private International Law and Its Work. In: CHENG, Chia-Jui. Collected Courses of the Xiamen Academy of International Law. Xiamen Academy of International Law Summer Courses, 2017.
VAN LOON, Hans. Towards a Global Hague Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil or Commercial Matters, Nederlands Internationaal Privaatrecht, 4-18, 2020.
WELLER, Matthias. The 2019 Hague Judgments Convention: The Jurisdictional Filters of the HCCH 2019 Judgments Convention. Yearbook of Private International Law 21, 2019/2020.
ZAMFIR, Ionel, European Parliamentary Research Service, “Peace, justice and strong institutions EU support for implementing SDG 16 worldwide”, PE 646.156, July 2022, available at https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2020/646156/EPRS_BRI(2020)646156_EN.pdf.
ZERK, Jennifer. Corporate Liability for Gross Human Rights Abuses: Towards a Fairer and More Effective System of Domestic Law Remedies. A report prepared for the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, 2014.
Téléchargements
Publié-e
Comment citer
Numéro
Rubrique
Licence
(c) Tous droits réservés Direito.UnB - Revue de Droit de l'Université de Brasília 2023
Cette œuvre est sous licence Creative Commons Attribution - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Pas de Modification 4.0 International.
Autores que publicam na Revista Direito.UnB concordam com os seguintes termos:
- Autores mantêm os direitos autorais e concedem à revista o direito de primeira publicação, com o trabalho simultaneamente licenciado sob a Licença Creative Commons - Atribuição-NãoComercial-SemDerivações 4.0 Internacional que permite o compartilhamento do trabalho com reconhecimento da autoria e publicação inicial nesta revista.
- Autores têm autorização para assumir contratos adicionais separadamente, para distribuição não-exclusiva da versão do trabalho publicada na Revista Direito.UnB (ex.: publicar em repositório institucional ou como capítulo de livro), com reconhecimento de autoria e publicação inicial nesta revista.
- Autores têm permissão e são incentivados a publicar e distribuir seu trabalho online (ex.: em repositórios institucionais ou em suas páginas pessoais) a qualquer momento após à definição do processo editorial.
- Autores concordam que, eventualmente, seus trabalhos poderão ser agregados pela Revista Direito.UnB às bases e sistemas de informação científica existentes (indexadores e bancos de dados atuais) ou que existam no futuro (indexadores e bancos de dados futuros). Os detentores dessas bases de dados terão a possibilidade de realizar as seguintes ações sobre o artigo:
- Reproduzir, transmitir e distribuir o artigo, no todo ou em parte sob qualquer forma ou meio de transmissão eletrônica existente ou desenvolvida no futuro, incluindo a transmissão eletrônica para fins de pesquisa, visualização e impressão;
- Reproduzir e distribuir, no todo ou em parte, o artigo na impressão;
- Capacidade de traduzir certas partes do artigo;
- Extrair figuras, tabelas, ilustrações e outros objetos gráficos e capturar metadados, legendas e artigo relacionado para fins de pesquisa, visualização e impressão;
- Transmissão, distribuição e reprodução por agentes ou autorizada pelos proprietários de distribuidoras de bases de dados;
- A preparação de citações bibliográficas, sumários e índices e referências de captura relacionados de partes selecionadas do artigo;
- Digitalizar e/ou armazenar imagens e texto de artigo eletrônico.
