Bochenski:
Attempts to Apply Logic to Problems of Religion
Keywords:
Logics of science, Scientific belief, Religions belief, Epistemology, BochenskiAbstract
The paper deals with four areas of problems of religion where logic is applied. The kind of application used is
mainly to take established laws and rules of formal logic but also to develop some new semantical relations. The first area is
that of levels of extension and intension: In religious texts, like in the Bible, but also in literature there are sometimes cases
where a word is a name (in the literal sense) for some object and this object is a name (in the metaphorical or spiritual sense)
for some other object. These semantical levels are analyzed by offering exact definitions. A further area is analogy where it is
shown how applied logic can help to offer definitions and analyze the important relations of analogy by proportionality and by
attribution. A third area is that of the problem of evil. It is shown that two very widespread arguments which attribute every evil
to God are either invalid or have false premisses. The last area of problems are those of an analysis of religious belief. It is
shown that there are not only differences between scientific and religious belief (as is expected) but also a lot of interesting
similarities.
Downloads
References
Bochenski, I.M. (1964). The logic of religion. New York: New York
University Press.
Weingartner, P. (1976). Wissenschaftstheorie II, 1. Grundlagenprobleme
der Logik und Mathematik. Stuttgart: Frommann.
Weingartner, P. (1979). Analogy among systems. Dialectica, 33,
355-378.
Weingartner, P. (Ed.) (1994). Scientific and religious belief. Philosophical
Studies Series 59. Dordrecht: Kluwer.