Restoration and disintegration: the legacy of medical tradition in Plato's Philebus
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14195/1984-249X_35_31Keywords:
Corpus hippocraticum, Philebus, Disintegration, Pleasure, MethodAbstract
This study aims to examine the position of medicine within the context of Plato's dialogue Philebus, focusing, on one hand, on the critique the philosopher makes of medicine as a practice and craft governed by specific norms and procedures, and, on the other, on the skillful way in which he draws upon certain medical theories, adapting them to serve his own purposes. The first part of the analysis seeks to understand the reasons behind Plato’s critique of medicine in the Philebus, especially in passage 56b1. This critique, as will be demonstrated, is closely related to the method of medicine. In this sense, it is important to highlight that, in criticizing medicine, Plato does not seek to establish a rivalry between philosophy and the medical practice, but rather to question medicine’s claim to sometimes present itself as the best and only modus vivendi. The second part of the study focuses on analyzing the influence of medicine on Plato’s theory of pleasure, particularly regarding the concept of pleasure as a process of fulfillment. To this end, Hippocratic texts such as On Diseases IV, On the Nature of Man, and On Ancient Medicine are consulted. Finally, through a comparison of recurring key terms, similarities and differences between the medical conception and Plato’s conception of pleasure are highlighted.
Downloads
References
AYACHE, L. (1999). Le fonds médical du Philèbe In: DIXSAUT, M. (ed.). La fêlure du plaisir Vol. 2. Paris, Vrin, p. 35-60.
BAILLY, A. (1935). Dictionnaire Grec - Français Paris, Hachette.
BLANCO, M. E. R. (2003). Sobre las enfermedades IV. In: BLANCO, M. E. R.; POLO, L. V.; CUENCA, J. C. Tratados Hipocráticos VIII (Traducciones, introducciones y notas). Madrid, Gredos.
BURNET, J. (ed.) (1900). Platonis Opera Vol. 2 e 3. Oxford, Clarendon Press.
CAIRUS, H. (1999). Da natureza do homem Corpus hippocraticum. História, Ciências, Saúde-Manguinhos 6, n. 2, p. 395-430.
CAIRUS, H. (2005a). Da natureza do homem. In: CAIRUS, H; JÚNIOR, W. Textos hipocráticos: o doente, o médico e a doença Rio de Janeiro, FIOCRUZ, p. 39-59.
CAIRUS, H. (2005b). Da doença sagrada. In: CAIRUS, H.; JÚNIOR, W. Textos hipocráticos: o doente, o médico e a doença . Rio de Janeiro, FIOCRUZ , p. 61-90.
COLLINS, J. H. (2015). Exhortations to Philosophy: The Protreptics of Plato, Isocrates, and Aristotle New York, Oxford University Press.
CRAIK, E. M. (2015). The ‘Hippocratic’ corpus: content and context Abingdon, Routledge.
DAVIDSON, D. (trad.) (1990). Platão. Philebus New York, Garland Publishing.
DIÈS, A. (trad.) (1993). Platon. Philèbe Paris, Les Belles Lettres.
FOSTER, M. (1970). Lectures on the History of Physiology. During the 16th-18th Centuries New York, Dover Publications.
GRENSEMANN, H. (1975). Knidische Medizin Teil 1: Die Testimonien zur ältesten knidischen Lehre und Analysen knidischer Schriften im Corpus hippocraticum Berlin/New York, De Gruyter.
GRENSEMANN, H. (1982). Hippokratische Gynäkologie. Die gynäkologischen Texte des Autors C nach den pseudohippokratischen Schriften De muliebribus I, IIund De Sterilibus Wiesbaden, Franz Steiner.
GRENSEMANN, H. (1987). Knidische Medizin , Teil II. Versuch einer weiteren Analyse der Schicht A in den pseudohippokratischen Schriften De natura muliebriund De muliebribus I und II Stuttgart, Franz Steiner Verlag.
HUGUENIN, R.; BRITO, R. P.; MATSUI, S. (2024). Hipócrates. Sobre a medicina antiga Apresentação de Silvio Marino. São Paulo, UNESP.
JOUANNA, J. (1990). Hippocrate: Tome II, Γ Partie - De l'ancienne médecine Paris, Les Belles Lettres .
JOUANNA, J. (2012). Greek Medicine from Hippocrate s to Galen: Selected Papers Leiden, Brill.
LEVIN, S. B. (2014). Plato’s Rivalry with Medicine: A Struggle and its Dissolution Oxford, Oxford University Press.
LIDDELL, H.; SCOTT, R. (1961). A Greek - English Lexicon JONES, H. (ed.). Oxford, Clarendon Press .
LITTRÉ, E. (1840). Oeuvres complètes d'Hippocrate . Paris, J. -B. Baillière.
LO PRESTI, R.; MARINO, S. (2011). Dialégesthai: fisiologia di un atto. Interazioni fra lessico medico e lessico filosofico fra V e IV secolo (Corpus Hippocraticum e Platone). Journal of Ancient Philosophy 5, n. 2, p. 1-41.
LOMBARD, J. (1999). Platon et la médecine. Le corps affaibli et l’âme attristée Paris, L’Harmattan.
LONIE, I. (1981). The Hippocrate s treatises “On generation”, “On the nature the child”, “Diseases IV”: a commentary Berlin/New York, De Gruyter .
LOPES, R. (2011). Platão. Timeu-Crítias (Tradução do grego, introdução, notas e índices). 1ed. Coimbra, Centro de Estudos Clássicos e Humanísticos.
MARINO, S. (2016). The Style of Medical Writing in the Speech of Eryximachus: Imitation and Contamination. In: CORNELLI, G. (ed.). Plato’s Styles and Characters: Between Literature and Philosophy Berlin/Boston, De Gruyter, p. 241-252
MARINO, S. (2019) Medicina. In: CORNELLI, G.; LOPES, R. (ed.). Platão Coimbra, Coimbra University Press, p. 347-358.
MARINO, S. (2024). De genitura - ΠΕΡΙ ΓΟΝΗΣ [Hipócrates]. Journal of Ancient Philosophy 18, n. 2, p. 82-112.
MIHAI, C. (2021). Protreptic and Medicine in Plato’s Early Dialogues. Hermeneia, n. 26, p. 14-26.
MUNIZ, F. (trad.) (2012). Platão Filebo São Paulo, Loyola.
NUTTON, V. (2013). Ancient Medicine New York, Routledge.
PRADEAU, J.-F. (trad.) (2002). Platão . Philèbe Paris, Flammarion.
PRADO, A. L. A. A. (trad.) (2014). Platão República 2 ed. São Paulo, Martins Fontes.
PULQUÉRIO, M. O. (trad.) (1991). Platão Górgias Coimbra, Universidade de Coimbra.
REIS, M. C. G. (trad.) (2016). Platão Fedro São Paulo, Penguin-Companhia.
VEGETTI, M. (1995). La medicina in Platone Venezia, Il Cardo.
VELANDIA, A. (2021). ¿Es Filolao el oponente del De prisca medicina?. Escritos 29, n. 63, p. 264-286.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Beatriz Saar
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Given the public access policy of the journal, the use of the published texts is free, with the obligation of recognizing the original authorship and the first publication in this journal. The authors of the published contributions are entirely and exclusively responsible for their contents.
1. The authors authorize the publication of the article in this journal.
2. The authors guarantee that the contribution is original, and take full responsibility for its content in case of impugnation by third parties.
3. The authors guarantee that the contribution is not under evaluation in another journal.
4. The authors keep the copyright and convey to the journal the right of first publication, the work being licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License-BY.
5. The authors are allowed and stimulated to publicize and distribute their work on-line after the publication in the journal.
6. The authors of the approved works authorize the journal to distribute their content, after publication, for reproduction in content indexes, virtual libraries and similars.
7. The editors reserve the right to make adjustments to the text and to adequate the article to the editorial rules of the journal.
