Diagoras of Melo and Theodore of Cyrene: two atheists?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14195/1984-249X_33_03Keywords:
Diagora of Melo, Theodore of Cyrene, Atheism, PreSocraticsAbstract
Diagoras and Theodorus are two of the atheists remembered in several catalogues of atheists in Antiquity, the first of which dates back to the 2nd century BC, and from then on invariably referredto by the ancients and to the present day as atheists. In fact, the atheism condemned in Athens had its roots in the pre-Socratic philosophical and scientific culture, whose fundamentally "materialistic" imprint is authoritatively testified to by Aristotle (MetaphysicsI 983b5-10). The philosophies of Anaximander, Anaximenes, Xenophanes, Heraclitus, Anaxagoras, Diogenes of Apollonia, and of course the Atomists and Sophists offered, albeit in different ways, not only some important support for the critique of traditional divinities, but also for the philosophical foundations of atheism. Diagoras has nothing to do with this tradition; even some events in his life may at most merit the accusation of being impious, but not of being an atheist. heodore appears to be of a different cultural temperament, close not only to the culture of the Cyrenaic school, but also to that of the Cynics and the Sophists. We have not only references to his philosophical doctrines, but also clear evidence of his atheism, having dedicated himself to "radically eliminating common beliefs in the gods". In conclusion, while Diagora's name can safely be removed from the catalogues of atheists, Theodore's is rightly included.
Downloads
References
Adorno [1961-1965] = Francesco Adorno, La filosofia antica, voll. 2, Feltrinelli, Milano, I [1961], II [1965].
Barnes [1979] = J. Barnes, The presocratic philosophers, voll. 2, London, Henley and Boston 1979.
Bonazzi [2020] = Mauro Bonazzi, Creature di un sol giorno, Einaudi, Torino 2020.
Brancacci [1982] = Teodoro l’ateo e Bione di Boristene fra Pirrone e Arcesilao, in «Elenchos» III, 1, 1982, pp. 55-85.
Brancacci [1990] = A. Brancacci, Oikeios logos. La filosofia del linguaggio di Antistene, Bibliopolis, Napoli 1990.
Casertano [1971] = G. Casertano, Natura e istituzioni umane nelle dotttrine dei sofisti, Napoli 1971.Curnis [2003] = Michele Curnis, Il Bellerofonte di Euripide. Edizione e commento dei frammenti, Edizioni dell’Orso, Alessandria 2003.
Decleva Caizzi [1966] = Antisthenis Fragmenta a cura di F. Decleva Caizzi, Cisalpino, Milano-Varese 1966.
Derenne [1930] = E. Derenne, Les procès d’impieté intentés aux philosophes à Athènes, aux V et IV siècles a.C., Lièges 1930.
DK = H. Diels-W. Kranz, Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, Dublin-Zürich 196813.
DL = Diogene Laerzio, Vite dei filosofi, a cura di M. Gigante, voll. 2, Laterza, Bari-Roma 1983.
Deschner = Karlheinz Deschner, Storia criminale del Cristianesimo, Ariete, Milano 2000-2005.
Dihle [1977] = Das Satyrspiele “Sisyphos”, in «Hermes» 105 (1977), pp. 28-42.Donini [1959] = A. Donini, Lineamenti di storia delle religioni, Editori Eiuniti, Roma 1959.
Drachmann [1922] = A. B. Drachmann, Atheism in the pagan antiquity, Chicago 1922.
Fahr [1969] = W. Fahr, ΘΕΟΥΣ ΝΟΜΙΖΕΙΝ. Zum Problem der Anfänge des Atheismus bei den Griechen, Olms, Hildesheim-New York 1969.
Farrington [1978] = B. Farrington, La scienza nell’antichità, Longanesi, Milano 1978.
Giannantoni [1958] = Gabriele Giannantoni, I Cirenaici, Sansoni, Firenze 1958.
Giannantoni [] = G. Giannantoni, Epicuro e l’ateismo antico, in AA.VV. [], «Atti del convegno internazionale di Napoli sull’epicureismo», pp.Giannantoni [1990] = Gabriele Giannantoni, Socratis et socraticorum reliquiae, 4 voll., Bibliopolis, Napoli 1990 (su Teodoro l’ateo vol. II, pp.119-133, e vol. IV, nota 20, pp.189-193.
Gigante [1983] = Diogene Laerzio, Vite dei filosofi, a cura di M. Gigante, voll. 2, Laterza, Bari-Roma 1983.
Giordano-Zecharya [2005] = M. Giordano-Zecharya, As Socrates Shows, the Athenians Did Not Believe in Gods, in «Numen» 52 3 (2005), pp. 325-355.
Gomperz [1896-1909] = Theodor Gomperz, Pensatori greci, voll. 4, La Nuova Italia, Firenze, I [1967], II [1964], III, 1-2 [1944], IV [1962].
Grilli [2001] = Aristofane, Le nuvole, a cura di A. Grilli, BUR, Milano 2002.
Hitchens [2006] = Chr. Hitchens, God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything, New York 2006.Hordern [2001] = J. Hordern, Philodemus and the poems of Diagoras, in «Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik», 136 (2001), pp. 33-38.
Jacobi [1959] = F. Jacobi, Diagoras ὁ Ἄθεος, Berlin 1959.
Janko [2001] = R. Janko, The Derveni Papyrus (Diagoras of Melos, Apopyrgizontes logoi?): a new translation, in «Classical Philology» 96.1 (2001), pp. 1-32.
Janko [2002-03] = R. Janko, God, science and Socrates, in «Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies», Vol. 46 (2002-03), pp. 1-18.
Kern [1975] = W. Kern, ATHEISMUS: Eine philosophiegeschichtliche Information, in «Zeitschrift für katholische Theologie, 97 1/2 (1975), pp. 3-40.
Lana [1950] = Italo Lana, Diagora di Melo, in «Atti dell’Accademia delle Scienze di Torino», 1950, pp. 161-205; poi con il titolo Diagora di Melo e la costituzione di Mantinea, in Studi sul pensiero politico classico, Guida, Napoli 1973, pp. 63-105.Levi [1966] = A. Levi, Storia della sofistica, Napoli 1966.
Ley [1966] = H. Ley, Geschichte der Aufklärung und des Atheismus, Berlin 1966.
Lintott [1982] = A. Lintott, Violence, civil strife and revolution in the Classical city, Baltimore 1982.
Mautner [1920-23] = E. Mautner, Der Atheismus und seine Geschichte in Abendlande, voll. 4, Stuttgart-Berlin 1920-1923.
Minois [2003] = Georges Minois, Storia dell’ateismo, Editori Riuniti, Roma 2003.
Mondolfo [1958] = R. Mondolfo, La comprensione del soggetto umano nell’antichitò classica, La Nuova Italia, Firenze 1958.
– Dictionnaire des athées, agnostiques, sceptiques et autres mécréants, Albin Michel, 2012.Nails [2002] = D. Nails, The people of Plato. A prosopografy of Plato and other Socratics, Indianapolis/Cambridge 2002.
O’Sullivan [1997] = L.L. O’Sullivan, Athenian Impiety Trials in the Late Fourth Century B. C., in «The Classical Quarterly» 47.1 (1997), pp. 136-152.
Romer [1996] = F.E. Romer, Diagoras the Melian (Diod. Sic. 13.6.7), in «Classical World» 89 (1996), pp. 393-401.
Rudhart [1960] = La définition du délit d'impiété d'après la législation attique, in «Museum Helveticum» 17 2 (1960), pp. 87-105.
Russo [1997] = Lucio Russo, La rivoluzione dimenticata, Feltrinelli. Milano 1997.
Santoro [1994] = M, Santoro, Sisifo e il presunto ateismo di Crizia, in «Orpheus» 15 2 (1994), p. 419-429.
Scott [1991] = Alan Scott, Origen and the Life of the Stars, Oxford 1991.
Sedley [2013] = D. Sedley, The Atheist Underground, in V. Harte-M. Lane (ed. by), Politeia in Greek and Roman Philosophy, Cambridge 2013, pp. 329-348Sutton [1981] = D. Sutton, Critias and Atheism, in «The Classical Quarterly , 31 1 (1981), pp. 33- 38
Tamagnone [2005] = Carlo Tamagnone, Ateismo filosofico nel mondo antico, Clinamen, Firenze 2005
Tresmontant [1972] = C. Tresmontant, Le problème de l’athéisme, Paris 1972.
Untersteiner [1961] = M. Untersteiner, Sofisti. Testimonianze e frammenti, voll. 4, Firenze 1961; il IV volume, Crizia, Firenze 1962, è a cura di A.M. Battegazzore.
Untersteiner [1967] = M. Untersteiner, I sofisti, voll. 2, Milano 1967.
Vallauri [1956] = G. Vallauri, Evemero di Messene, Torino 1956.
Winiarczyk [1976] = M. Winiarczyk, Der erste Atheistenkatalog des Kleitomachos, in «Philologus» 120 (1976), pp. 32-46.Winiarczyk [1979] = M. Winiarczyk, Diagoras von Melos. Wahrheit und Legende, in «Eos» 67 [1979], pp. 191-213, 68 [1980], pp. 51-75.
Winiarczyk [1981a] = M. Winiarczyk, Diagoras Melius, Theodorus Cyraenaeus, edidit W. Winiarczyk, Teubner, Leipzig 1981
Winiarczyk [1981b] = M. Winiarczyk, Theodoros Ὁ ἊΘΕΟΣ, in «Philologus» CXXV (1981), pp. 64-94
Winiarczyk [1984] = M. Winiarczyk, Wer galt im Altertum als Atheist?, in «Philologus» 128 (1984), pp. 157-183
Winiarczyk [1989] = M. Winiarczyk, Bibliographie zum antiken Atheismus, in «Elenchos» X 1 (1989), pp. 103-192
Winiarczyk [2016] = Marek Winiarczyk, Diagoras of Melos. A contribution to the history of ancient atheism, de Gruyter, Berlin-Boston 2016
Whitmarsh [2015] = T. Whitmarsh, Battling the Gods: Atheism in the Ancient World, New York 2015Whitmarsh [2016] = T. Whitmarsh, Diagoras, Bellerophon and the siege of Olympus, «Journal of Hellenic Studies» 136 (2016), pp. 182-186
Woodbury [1965] = L. Woodbury, The date and atheism of Diagoras of Melos, in «Phoenix» 19.3 (1965), pp. 178-211
Zeller-Mondolfo [1892 sgg.] = E.Zeller-R. Mondolfo, La filosofia dei Greci nel suo sviluppo storico, La Nuova Italia, Firenze; I, 1 [1967], a cura di R. Mondolfo; I, 2 [1967], a cura di R. Mondolfo; I, 3 [1967], a cura di G. Reale; I, 4 [1961], a cura di R. Mondolfo; I, 5 [1969], a cura di A. Capizzi;
Zeppi [2003] = Stelio Zeppi, Il pensiero religioso nei presocratici (Alle radici dell’ateismo), Edizioni Studium, Roma 2003
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Giovanni Casertano
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Given the public access policy of the journal, the use of the published texts is free, with the obligation of recognizing the original authorship and the first publication in this journal. The authors of the published contributions are entirely and exclusively responsible for their contents.
1. The authors authorize the publication of the article in this journal.
2. The authors guarantee that the contribution is original, and take full responsibility for its content in case of impugnation by third parties.
3. The authors guarantee that the contribution is not under evaluation in another journal.
4. The authors keep the copyright and convey to the journal the right of first publication, the work being licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License-BY.
5. The authors are allowed and stimulated to publicize and distribute their work on-line after the publication in the journal.
6. The authors of the approved works authorize the journal to distribute their content, after publication, for reproduction in content indexes, virtual libraries and similars.
7. The editors reserve the right to make adjustments to the text and to adequate the article to the editorial rules of the journal.
