Plotinus and Augustine on evil and matter

Keywords: Augustine, Plotinus, matter, evil, non-being

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to examine whether and, if so, how far, the Augustinian notion of malum is related to Plotinus’ concept of evil, as it appears in Ennead I. 8 [51]. The Augustinian notion of evil will be analyzed by focusing on the De natura boni, considering plurality and unity in Augustine’s identification of malum and nihil, both in their ontological and axiological dimensions. Topics selected for special consideration will be, first, evil as lack of modus, species and ordo naturalis (De nat. b., 4), and, secondly, corruptio as cause of defectio boni (De nat. b., 6). The second part will analyze Plotinus’ notion of evil, as spelled out in Ennead I, 8 [51], considering the Plotinian identity of to kakon and me on. Topics selected for analysis will be, first, the concept of evil as lack of measure, form and order (Enn. I. 8. 3), and secondly, the notion of to kakon as lack of good (Enn. I. 8. 5) simpliciter.  The third part of this paper will consider the differences between Augustine’s and Plotinus’ identity of evil and non-being, as related to the notion of matter. Topics selected for analysis will be, firstly, Plotinus’ identity of matter and evil (Enn. I. 8. 10), and, secondly, Augustine’s concept of matter as capacitas formarum (De nat. b., 18). The conclusion will bring out how Plotinus’ concept of steresis suggests both a different relation between evil and non-being while being closely resembling Augustine’s pattern of malum and nihil.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

ARMSTRONG, A. H. (1966). Plotinus. Ennead I (translation). Cambridge, Harvard University Press.
BEIERWALTES, W. (1994). Agostino e il neoplatonismo cristiano. Milan, Vita e Pensiero.
BETTETINI, M. (1994). La misura delle cose: struttura e modelli dell’universo secondo Agostino d’Ippona. Milan, Rusconi.
BEZANÇON, J. N. (1965). Le mal et l’existence temporelle chez Plotin et Saint Augustin. Recherches Augustiniennes 3. p. 133-160.
CATAPANO, G. (2006). Introduzione Generale. In: Aurelio Agostino. Tutti i dialoghi. Milan. Bompiani, p. IX-CLXVI.
CHIARADONNA, R. (2009). Plotino. Urbino, Carocci editore.
CORRIGAN, K. (1996). Plotinus’ Theory of MatterEvil and the Question of Substance: Plato, Aristotle, and Alexandre of Aphrodisias. Leeuven, Peeters.
DE CAPITANI, F. (1980). «Corruptio» negli scritti antimanichei di S. Agostino. I. Rivista di Filosofia Neoscolastica 72. p. 640-669; (1981). II, 73. p. 132-156.
DI SILVA, M. F. (2015). Agostino e il problema del negativo. Pluralità e unità dell’identità di male e nulla. In: ALICI, L. (ed.). I conflitti religiosi nella scena pubblica. Roma. Città Nuova, p. 105-118.
MÜLLER, C. (1986). Corruptio-incorruptio. In: MAYER, C. (ed.). Augustinus-Lexikon. Basel. Schwabe, p. 47-53.
LA BONNARDIÈRE, A. M. (1970). Biblia Augustiniana. Paris (France), Études Augustiniennes.
MOON, A. A. (1955). The De Natura Boni of Saint Augustine (translation). Washington, Catholic University of America Press.
NARBONNE, J. M. (1994). La Métaphysique de Plotin. Paris (France), Vrin.
O’BRIEN, D. (1971). Plotinus on evil: a study of matter and the soul in Plotinus’ conception of human evil. In: SCHUHL, M.; HADOT, P. (eds.). Le Néoplatonisme: Royaumont, 9-13 juin 1969. Paris. Editions du Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, p. 113-146.
O’BRIEN, D. (1996). Plotinus on matter and evil. In: GERSON, L. P. (ed.). The Cambridge Companion to Plotinus. Cambridge. The Cambridge University Press, p. 171-195.
O’MEARA, D. (1999). Introduction. In: Plotin. Traité 51 (I, 8). Paris. Éditions du Cerf, p. 11-41.
REALE, G. (2001). Introduzione. In: Aurelio Agostino. Natura del bene. Milan. Bompiani, p. 13-103.
RIST, J. (1961). Plotinus on matter and evil. Phronesis 6. p. 151-164.
RIST, J. (1974). Plotinus and Augustin on evil. In: AA. VV., Plotino e il Neoplatonismo in Oriente e in Occidente (Roma, 5-9 ottobre 1970). Rome, Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei.
ROCHE, W. J. (1941). Measure, Number, and Weight in St. Augustine. New Scholasticism 15. p. 350-376.
SCHÄFER, C. (2004). Matter in Plotinus’s Normative Ontology. Phronesis 143. p. 266-294.
Published
2018-04-17
How to Cite
Di SilvaM. F. (2018). Plotinus and Augustine on evil and matter. Archai: The Origins of Western Thought, (23), 205. https://doi.org/10.14195/1984-249X_23_7